ADVERTISEMENT

OT: College Football seems a bit broken

jeramye

Well-Known Member
Feb 1, 2006
1,615
5,750
113
4 of the top 10 lost to unranked opponents and in those games even the unranked teams didn't play great. Syracuse was great in spots, but made a ton of the mistakes that normally get you beat by any top 10 team. LSU didn't play good ball. Arizona St still has a completely broken offense and beat a Top 10 team anyway...that shouldn't happen. And Chris Peterson, who is lauded as one of the smartest guys in CFB made boneheaded decisions that made me think Gus was in his headset.

Florida keeps going to ATL for the title game with no offense, no QB play and generally is laughed at by anyone who has followed or covered the game for a few decades. You have quite a few ranked teams that have fan bases who would love to fire their coaches on any given week and it's not because they are impatient idiots...it's because their HC's often look like idiots themselves.

What broke football? We've got nearly every HC out there making $3-5 million per season minimum. This product is craptastic while programs have more support staff than they used to, more sports science and advanced stats than they've ever used and all I'm seeing is 90% of games that look like teams that don't practice being coached by men that get paid a fortune to not know how to use TO's, can't understand basic situational football and often can't get their special teams onto the field quickly enough to not use a TO or get a flag for delay or too many men. I find this astounding.

Am I crazy in that todays low scoring SEC games look like UT vs South Carolina yesterday instead of that 7-6 LSU vs AU game where we shut down Russell....and that one of those was high quality, hard nosed, well coached football between 2 good teams and one is standard mediocrity laced with bad coaching? Has the money somehow made coaching worse? I'm not sure I understand what's going on, but watching games the last few years, and not just AU games, makes me think the overall quality of play is significantly below what we used to see....and a ton of that seems to look like bad coaching to me.
 
One one solution now. Get rid of college football and basketball and focus all energy in soccer and let's try to win the World Cup. With the concussion crap football won't last too much longer anyway...

Corch Houston can be the USMNT Coach.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fairfield35064
Practice time is limited and a handful of schools are stockpiling talent that would've been more dispersed 10 years ago.
This does matter. However I think this is giving multi-millionaire coaches a bit of a pass if we put too much on it. I think you have 5% of HCs that have the personality that would drive them to work 100 hrs a week if they were billionaires with 30 trophies. The rest are driven guys, but the drive dissipates a bit when you've been in the game for decades and you are financially secure for life. Hell you can part time consult or do some TV and make nice cash now in semi-retirement.

I'm seeing too many teams that look like they don't know what the hell is going on. Seeing too many totally botched situations in game management that tell me coaches aren't even looking at that stuff which would seem to be a basic. Outside of 2 teams in the league, convince me these staffs are legit putting in overtime weekly that isn't spent playing Candy Crush on their phones or setting up hookers for their next recruiting trip. It looks to me like what you see at a company when junior with the coke habit takes over and leaves work to play golf 3 times a week saying he's with customers. The company is still running, but it's running on empty. That's what AU/LSU/UT/Arky/UF/OM/Mizzou and others look like to me.
 
Saban killed cfb

the NFL is a far superior product and much more enjoyable imho
college football is games played amongst not that talented children. Corched by guys that are paid because they know how to suck up to hulking teens not cause they know how to coach ball. The level of play is not in the same stratosphere.

Then you factor in the practice restrictions. Kids not playing the sport as much. General lack of focus/ toughness of younger generations.

One thing I will say cfb due to its absurd no playoff system forever the fans have this ridiculous notion you're supposed to win every game. Upsets happen all the time in sports but people freak about them in cfb.
 
college football is games played amongst not that talented children. Corched by guys that are paid because they know how to suck up to hulking teens not cause they know how to coach ball. The level of play is not in the same stratosphere.

Then you factor in the practice restrictions. Kids not playing the sport as much. General lack of focus/ toughness of younger generations.

One thing I will say cfb due to its absurd no playoff system forever the fans have this ridiculous notion you're supposed to win every game. Upsets happen all the time in sports but people freak about them in cfb.

that's a good point and applies to everyone but Saban

also why cbb is so good. you can afford to drop a few games, but its all about making it into the tourney and then get hot
 
Saban killed cfb

the NFL is a far superior product and much more enjoyable imho
I don't disagree with your first statement. The accumulation of talent into one program has made others in the region much weaker than they would've been with more traditional dispersion of talent. I think there's still enough talent for 3-4 SEC teams to be very good each season with better ADs and HCs but you won't see 5-6 extremely strong teams most seasons anymore.
 
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest posts

ADVERTISEMENT