man, looks like Rob Pate has pulled the plug on Gus as well.
Rob Pate: Gus Malzahn's shortcomings are no longer defensible
The Gus Bus is in disrepair. It is broken and untenable.
It is not entirely Gus Malzahn's fault. Against Tennessee he had too many players in position to succeed but simply fail to make the play. Still, it is wholly his responsibility.
The frustration with the Malzahn regime — the up and down, schizophrenic, consistently inconsistent Auburn identity — has worn thin and demolished any cache of Malzahn goodwill. He has lost the majority and I believe it is irretrievable.
I don’t enjoy writing that because I like
Gus Malzahn. I like the character and selectivity of the kids he chases on the recruiting trail and their representation of themselves and our university upon their arrival. I like that he attempts to run a clean program, is a good human being that sees his profession as a ministry opportunity to young people. I can not unremember the offensive onslaught he unleashed upon his arrival, the improbable turnaround of 2013, or the elation unleashed on our campus last fall with consecutive dominating victories over our rivals positioned at No. 1 in the land. His teams never quit. His teams are often in it until the final possession.
But for every stair-stepped, incremental gain there comes a sudden free-fall, an avalanche of inexplicable, undeniable failure that is no longer defensible. At some point you must recognize and rightly deduce the continued duds aren’t the outliers — the lofty successes are.
Malzahn has been close to scaling the wall in his tenure, but his teams have not finished and consistently fall flat along the way. There is seemingly a disconnect between the practice field and the bright lights of SEC venues as the lone supremely consistent aspect of this program has been stellar practices without matching outcomes.
When long-running SEC losing streaks are ending on your field, when average quarterbacks put up career-high gains and display uncanny accuracy, when one-dimensional offenses have their way with the strength of your team, when struggling defenses find their footing against your offense — problems abound. Sometimes your opponent is just better and you tip your hat to that supremacy. The college football world knows that is not the case, however. That’s why every victory over this team means so very much to those programs.
Worse than opponents successes at Auburn’s expense is Auburn’s regression in areas that simply baffle and where regression cannot occur. An argument could be made for each of Auburn’s quarterbacks. They have gotten worse the longer they were in the program: Jarrett Stidham’s regression is the most alarming. What looked like a surefire NFL talent has devolved into a shell of his former self.
Feeling the pressure to make a play for his team, Stidham’s decision making has been freshman-esque and his inability to protect the football has proven costly. His confidence is low, his protection is nonexistent, his running game is below average and his willingness to surrender his body to extend the drive is below that of his peers. No position has defined the Auburn offense like quarterback play and Stidham’s regression is directly proportional to Auburn’s lack of success.
Another area you simply can’t play so poorly to win in this league is along the offensive line. Finding five guys that can effectively communicate, that can drive block, that can give a quarterback any semblance of time shouldn’t be such an impossible endeavor six years into a coaching staff. The fact that it is displays poor roster management, poor evaluations, poor development or poor coaching. This is a lineman’s league. Those that control the trenches raise the hardware. Those that get eaten alive up front end up searching for new coaches.
The reasons for finding ourselves in this predicament are long, exhaustive, beyond one man’s opinion in one column. It started with the university and a three-man committee choosing comfort over a proven resume. It extends to the president of the university getting taken to the woodshed by agent Jimmy Sexton in contract negotiations and its tentacles reach all things Auburn football.
Now a decision has to be made. Can we afford to cut ties with coach
Gus Malzahn versus can we afford not to? There are no good choices in this debacle. The optics are horrible as is the mountain of money either decision will entail.
It is a brutal profession where few find sustained success. It is a brutal sport where one’s failure results in the units demise, and where a physical pounding is a prerequisite for participation. It is a brutal conference where the demarcation between champion and pauper is razor thin. It is a brutal state, where Auburn enjoys little sympathy competing against the best to ever coach college football — in a state dominated by fans, media and traditional success from the in-state power.
64COMMENTS
Don’t cry for Auburn. Contend for her. Rise up and demand better. The Auburn family can take no more of this cyclical whiplash nonsense. Be bold. Be decisive. Most importantly, restore belief.
Rob Pate is a former Auburn defensive back. His columns appear exclusively at Auburn Undercover.