Mac is a tricky one... everyone loves him - and for good reason... and I love the guy too - but it seems to come across at hate when I talk about his deficiencies... hopefully we have a group more capable of nuanced thought here though
my contention has never been than Mac is a finished product or that he’s not capable of improving his game, I just thought it was a 4 year process, and he was already receiving undue credit for parts of his game that were nowhere near consistent...
he’s not a great defensive player yet... he’s barely a good defender, and only by comparison to the atrocious defenders around him last year... and his best defensive contributions are helping or off ball, rarely as a primary defender... to his credit, he maximizes those opportunities better than anyone else on the team, and he deserves more time as a result, but he has the same issues as Horace with fouling far too much as a primary defender, and leaving offensive rebounding opportunities for the opponent by taking himself out of the play trying to block or alter shots he can’t reach... as a result he’s not dependable for more than 20ish minutes a night, which means he’s perfect for his current role, but expecting and asking for more isn’t the grand slam lock his fans seem to think
offensively, I’ll just say I don’t believe for a second that he’s ready to take and make 3’s consistently... he made the 1 he took last year, but the release was SO slow, and the hitch SO pronounced, and footwork SO clumsy, and overall stroke was SO mechanical - you could tell he was thinking through every single step of the process... if that gets cured in 8 months, then I don’t care what else Chuck did - he should be granted a full pardon and tour the country laying hands on broken jumpers like Jesus Christ because he’s a miracle worker... doesn’t mean Mac can’t get there, because he’s smart and obviously works hard, but that’s not a quick fix...
he was also a disaster trying to initiate offense on the perimeter..,at least twice late in the conference season he got the ball 30 feet from the basket, turned, and threw it straight to the other team... he just turned and threw the ball to where the play said the next action should go - with no regard for reading a defense or adjusting mid-play... the only thing he could be trusted to do offensively was pick and roll or rim run on the break... and he was GREAT at both... but it wasn’t hyperbole when I said he was an absolute zero with the ball more than 2 feet from the basket... if anything he was a net negative offensively anywhere more than 2 feet from the basket... doesn’t mean he’ll stay that way, and I never claimed he would, but from where he was last year to his rumored current status - the leap is SO large that it’s unfathomable to me
now, for the good, even with all that, he’s so good as a backup big, and his energy and effort are so high that I have no doubt he’s improved somewhat, and will continue to improve the entire time he’s here - so he gets slotted in at #5 on my rankings